The Pittsburgh Pirates' Starting Rotation: A Battle for the Fifth Spot
The Pittsburgh Pirates are gearing up for the upcoming season, with their starting rotation largely set, but a fierce competition for the final spot remains. Among the contenders is right-handed pitcher José Urquidy, who recently signed a one-year, $1.5 million contract with the Pirates. Urquidy will make his Spring Training debut against the Minnesota Twins at LECOM Park on February 26th, aiming to secure a place in the starting rotation and demonstrate his ability to pitch consistently at the major league level.
The Pirates already have a strong foundation in their starting rotation, with four pitchers who will likely start for most of the season: Paul Skenes, Mitch Keller, Braxton Ashcraft, and Bubba Chandler. However, Urquidy is determined to prove his worth and challenge for that coveted fifth spot.
Urquidy's Journey to the Pirates
Urquidy's path to the Pirates is intertwined with the Pirates' new pitching coach, Bill Murphy. Murphy, who was Urquidy's pitching coach with the Astros, played a pivotal role in Urquidy's success during his final three seasons with the team. During this period, Urquidy posted solid numbers, contributing significantly to the Astros' rotation.
Statistical Overview
- Total Record: 24-14 (58/65)
- ERA: 4.09 (334.1 innings)
- Strikeouts/Walks: 269/82
- WHIP: 1.16
- K/9 (K/BB): 7.2 (3.28)
Urquidy's most impressive season came in 2022, where he made 28 starts in 29 appearances for Houston, boasting a 13-8 record, a 3.94 ERA over 164.1 innings, 134 strikeouts, and a .244 BAA. Despite pitching just once in the postseason, Urquidy earned a World Series ring, showcasing his resilience and playoff experience.
Injury Concerns and Recovery
However, Urquidy's recent performance has been hampered by injuries. The past two seasons have been challenging, with limited pitching opportunities. In 2023, he missed three months due to right shoulder discomfort, and in 2024, he underwent Tommy John surgery, ending his season. Urquidy made a comeback in August of the previous season, primarily playing for Triple-A Toledo in the Detroit Tigers' system.
During his rehab assignment, Urquidy posted a 2.91 ERA over 21.2 innings in eight starts and 11 games, showcasing his determination to recover and return to the major leagues. Despite his recent struggles, the Pirates believe that Urquidy, if healthy, could provide valuable production in 2026, all while being under a relatively inexpensive contract.
The Battle for the Fifth Spot
The Pirates' fifth spot in the starting rotation is hotly contested, with several pitchers vying for the position. Carmen Mlodzinski and Hunter Barco are also in the running, with Mlodzinski already making his Grapefruit League start and Barco set to face the St. Louis Cardinals on March 1st. Urquidy's experience and Murphy's guidance give him an edge, but he must prove his ability to fill the final spot in the rotation during Spring Training.
As the Pirates prepare for the season, the battle for the fifth spot in the starting rotation promises to be intriguing, with Urquidy and his competitors vying for a chance to showcase their skills and contribute to the team's success.
